How We Decide What to Audit
Our work starts with an annual risk assessment of Touro University's audit universe, the full set of schools, campuses, departments, and processes we could review. We use Touro's organizational structure in Banner to define that universe.
For each area, we consider risks in five categories: financial, compliance, fraud, information technology, and information security. We also draw on input from the Audit Committee, senior management, and Touro's Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) program.
The results drive a risk-based internal audit plan. The Chief Internal Auditor presents the plan to the Audit Committee of the Board of Trustees for approval, updates it as risks change, and tells the Committee about any significant risk the plan cannot cover with available resources.
Example Internal Audit Plan
This example shows the format of a plan. It is illustrative only and does not describe actual engagements.
| Area | Type of Engagement | Risk Rating | Estimated Hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compliance | Assurance (Audit) | Critical | 440 |
| Payroll | IT Audit | Critical | 440 |
| Accounting | Assurance (Audit) | High | 440 |
| Vendor Management | Limited-Scope Audit | High | 220 |
| Human Resources | Compliance Audit | Medium | 440 |
| Enterprise Risk Management | Advisory (ERM Facilitation) | Not Rated | 150 |
| Total | 2,130 |
A real plan also compares the total with the hours available and shows any shortfall, so the Audit Committee can see the effect of resource limits.
How an Audit Works
A typical assurance engagement takes about nine weeks from announcement to final report, followed by follow-up until all agreed actions are complete. Timing varies with the size and complexity of the area.
1. Planning (about 4 weeks)
- Announcement memo. We notify the area's management of the engagement, its objectives, and its timing.
- Entrance meeting. We meet with management to discuss objectives, scope, timing, key contacts, and an initial information request.
- Understanding the process. Through interviews, document review, and walkthroughs, we learn how the process works and identify its key controls.
- Engagement risk assessment. We identify the risks to the area's objectives, apply any IIA Topical Requirements that fit (for example, cybersecurity or third-party risk), and record risks and controls in a risk and control matrix.
- Engagement plan and work program. We set the final objectives, scope, and testing procedures.
2. Fieldwork (about 3 weeks)
- We test whether key controls are well designed and operating effectively, using methods such as sampling, inspection, reperformance, and data analysis.
- We document our work and evidence to the department's standards, and senior auditors review it.
- We discuss potential findings with management as they arise, so there are no surprises.
3. Reporting (about 2 weeks)
- Draft report. We prepare findings (criteria, condition, cause, and effect), rated by significance, with recommendations and an overall engagement conclusion.
- Exit meeting. We review the draft with management to confirm the facts and agree on management action plans with owners and target dates.
- Final report. We issue the report to the area's management and the President, and report significant results to the Audit Committee.
4. Follow-up
- We track every management action plan to completion.
- When management reports an action as done, we perform closure verification testing to confirm the fix works.
- We report the status of open actions to the Audit Committee each quarter. If management decides to accept a risk that exceeds Touro's risk appetite, the Chief Internal Auditor escalates it to the Committee.
Advisory Engagements and Investigations
- Advisory engagements, such as ERM facilitation or advice on controls for a new system, follow a lighter version of the same steps. We agree on the objectives, scope, and deliverables with management at the start, and management keeps responsibility for decisions and implementation.
- Investigations of suspected fraud or misconduct follow a separate, confidential process coordinated with the Office of the General Counsel and Human Resources. Results go to the President and, for significant matters, the Audit Committee.
What We Ask of You
- Name a primary contact and provide requested information promptly.
- Tell us early about known issues, recent changes, or concerns in your area.
- Review draft findings carefully and agree on realistic action plans, owners, and dates.
- Complete agreed actions on time and tell us when they are done.
More Information
The full Internal Audit Policy and Procedures are in TouroOne, under the Policies tab in Employee Policies. Our work is performed in conformance with the IIA's Global Internal Audit Standards and the Internal Audit Charter.